TSLA404.660-6.49%
GM82.510-1.555%
F14.430-0.34%
RIVN15.930-0.75%
CYD50.460-1.37%
HMC26.850-0.12%
TM178.190-2.03%
CVNA70.0101.11%
PAG180.7600.695%
LAD307.500-1.02%
AN195.8602.47%
GPI325.600-0.14%
ABG199.8200.27%
SAH83.650-0.06%
TSLA404.660-6.49%
GM82.510-1.555%
F14.430-0.34%
RIVN15.930-0.75%
CYD50.460-1.37%
HMC26.850-0.12%
TM178.190-2.03%
CVNA70.0101.11%
PAG180.7600.695%
LAD307.500-1.02%
AN195.8602.47%
GPI325.600-0.14%
ABG199.8200.27%
SAH83.650-0.06%
TSLA404.660-6.49%
GM82.510-1.555%
F14.430-0.34%
RIVN15.930-0.75%
CYD50.460-1.37%
HMC26.850-0.12%
TM178.190-2.03%
CVNA70.0101.11%
PAG180.7600.695%
LAD307.500-1.02%
AN195.8602.47%
GPI325.600-0.14%
ABG199.8200.27%
SAH83.650-0.06%

Why your dealership should double-down on fixed-operations – Jim Roche

2020 has posed many challenges for the automotive industry. However, car dealers have been extraordinarily resilient. We have seen the majority of dealers implement digital toolsets and adapt their operations to meet shoppers’ needs wherever, and however, they want to shop. The same can be said for the fixed-operations department. Service directors have added pressure and a unique set of both challenges and opportunities. Today, we speak with Jim Roche, founder of WarrCloud about the lessons learned from this year and how service departments can improve in 2021.

Many industry analysts are predicting that the 2020 SAAR will most likely end up around 14.5 million despite the tight grip of the Coronavirus. 2021 is likely to be a different story with analysts predicting a SAAR of 15.5 million. However, these numbers are still a far cry from the consistent 17 million in the last five years.

In Roche’s opinion, the longer-term trends of margin compression for both new and used vehicles are going to re-assert themselves. With this in mind, the big lesson of 2020 according to Roche is to invest in the fixed-operations department. If service wasn’t the backbone of the dealership before, it certainly is now. According to NADA, service was more than 50% of dealership gross in 2019. That trend is projected to continue through 2021.

At Roche’s latest venture, WarrCloud, the company conducted market research where they asked dealers and service leaders a variety of different questions about their plans for 2021. Overwhelmingly, this group said that expense optimization in service is of the utmost importance. Despite coming off of a strong year, they are looking for ways to improve the gross that service generates. One way to do this is to outsource labor which Roche believes will be a trend in 2021.

Pickup service and delivery are here to stay as well. According to myKaarma, overall pickup and delivery tripled between October 2019 and October 2020. Top dealers are processing over 1,000 pickup and delivery orders every month, and the overall dealer average is 190 per month. 91% of customers also said that they prefer dealerships that offer pickup and delivery services. It is an incredible loyalty and revenue driver.

For more great insight and advice from Jim Roche, be sure to watch the full interview above.


Did you enjoy this interview with Jim Roche? Please share your thoughts, comments, or questions regarding this topic with host Jim Fitzpatrick at jfitzpatrick@cbtnews.com.

Be sure to follow us on Facebook and Twitter to stay up to date or catch-up on all of our podcasts on demand.

While you’re here, don’t forget to subscribe to our email newsletter for all the latest auto industry news from CBT News.

More from Fixed-Ops
The dealership growth strategy hiding in plain sight. Affinitiv CEO Sharon Kitzman says dealership must reconnect sales and service to drive conversions and protect loyalty in a tough market.

The dealership growth strategy hiding in plain sight

- June 9, 2026
With economic uncertainty prompting consumers to hold onto vehicles longer, dealerships are looking to their existing customer base to generate demand. Sharon Kitzman, CEO of Affinitiv, joins us on today’s...
5 key things killing your service advisor training (and how to fix them)

5 key things killing your service advisor training (and how to fix them)

- June 1, 2026
Service departments continue to invest heavily in advisor training, yet many dealerships still fail to see lasting gains in CSI, sales performance, retention, and customer experience. Joining us on today’s...
Piazza Auto Group doubles down on service fundamentals, advisor accountability 

Piazza Auto Group doubles down on service fundamentals, advisor accountability 

- May 25, 2026
As affordability concerns continue to reshape dealership operations, Piazza Auto Group is reverting to the basics. During the latest episode of Service Drive, Dave Rogers, Fixed Operations Director at Piazza Auto...
The simple 'paperwork' mistake that could cost dealers $10,000

The simple ‘paperwork’ mistake that could cost dealers $10,000

- May 13, 2026
On the Dash: CDK Global says a paperwork problem cost a dealer $10,000 during a manufacturer audit. NADA calls federal record-keeping requirements among the most burdensome rules dealers face today. ...