TSLA410.060-12.18%
GM73.100-1.76%
F13.030-0.37%
RIVN13.350-0.44%
CYD50.4400.44%
HMC25.210-0.97%
TM187.370-3.31%
CVNA66.030-1.14%
PAG159.750-2.43%
LAD264.8902.97%
AN181.940-2.21%
GPI317.1803.56%
ABG176.280-2.89%
SAH74.0600.1%
TSLA410.060-12.18%
GM73.100-1.76%
F13.030-0.37%
RIVN13.350-0.44%
CYD50.4400.44%
HMC25.210-0.97%
TM187.370-3.31%
CVNA66.030-1.14%
PAG159.750-2.43%
LAD264.8902.97%
AN181.940-2.21%
GPI317.1803.56%
ABG176.280-2.89%
SAH74.0600.1%
TSLA410.060-12.18%
GM73.100-1.76%
F13.030-0.37%
RIVN13.350-0.44%
CYD50.4400.44%
HMC25.210-0.97%
TM187.370-3.31%
CVNA66.030-1.14%
PAG159.750-2.43%
LAD264.8902.97%
AN181.940-2.21%
GPI317.1803.56%
ABG176.280-2.89%
SAH74.0600.1%

How digital auto insurance can enhance the customer experience at your dealership – Jay Hicks | Polly

Today, it’s all about providing a great customer experience in all areas of the sales process while also increasing your bottom line. Joining us in the studio is Jay Hicks, Senior Vice President of Strategic Partnerships at Polly, formerly known as DealerPolicy. In this edition of Inside Automotive, Jay discusses the value of auto insurance technology and why it is crucial to providing the best customer experience for car buyers.

Digital auto insurance integrated at the point of sale is becoming an increasingly popular part of the retail process. Historically, car buyers would spend a lot of their time and energy finding and comparing the best rates. Polly’s digital auto insurance marketplace allows customers to compare personalized quotes from over 40 carriers in minutes. This solution gives control back to the customer, who can then confidently choose the right policy. The dealer can also participate in this process and earn gross on the backend. Polly is the insurance agency 

“What we’re trying to do, is make insurance part of the process,” says Hicks. “Make it pervasive and let the consumer understand that it’s not as difficult as [they] think.”

Polly is an insurance agency that strives to enhance the customer experience and understand how car dealers work. The company’s co-founders, Travis Fitzgerald and Jeff Mungen wanted to modernize the process and offer consumers choices. On average, consumers save $65 per month after shopping with Polly, which means those savings could be used toward other F&I products.

“Our goal is to write everybody,” explains Hicks. “We have the big national carriers; Progressive, Nationwide, Safeco, Travellers, etc. We have a wide variety of regional carriers as well, trying to write the full band of customers.”

Many of the employees at Polly have automotive experience, and the company is very partner-focused, especially in the F&I space. This year, Polly has partnered with JM&A Group and Assurant on the direct F&I side. These partners are in the dealership every day and can help car dealers think through processes and solutions. In fact, the average backend PVR lift is around $535 per unit when a policy is written. This amount will be even more meaningful as interest rates rise and the industry works to bring back new vehicle supply.

Click here to learn more about enrolling your dealership, at no cost, with Polly today.


Did you enjoy this interview with Jay Hicks? Please share your thoughts, comments, or questions regarding this topic by submitting a letter to the editor here, or connect with us at newsroom@cbtnews.com.

Be sure to follow us on Facebook and Twitter to stay up to date or catch up on all of our podcasts on demand.

While you’re here, don’t forget to subscribe to our email newsletter for all the latest auto industry news from CBT News.

dealers

More from F&I
Why 'decision fatigue' is killing your F&I gross

Why ‘decision fatigue’ is killing your F&I gross

- May 14, 2026
Buying a car demands more decisions than many customers expect. By the time they sign the purchase agreement, "decision fatigue" has set in. They have already negotiated a price, settled...
Getting more buyers across the finish line

Getting more buyers across the finish line

- May 13, 2026
Every car shopping journey has its highs and lows. On the positive side, it’s fun to do test drives and it’s exhilarating to drive off the lot in a new...
Finance Director Symphony Wills shares her success story

Finance Director shares path from rejection to BMW rooftop success

- May 12, 2026
Symphony Wills did not stumble into the car business. She chased it, fought rejection, and took on a two-hour commute to get her foot in the door and onto the...
Affordability squeeze reshapes F&I strategy as dealers rethink customer conversations

Affordability squeeze reshapes F&I strategy as dealers rethink customer conversations

- May 7, 2026
Rising costs are reshaping how customers approach car buying, and F&I leaders must adjust their strategies to keep pace. On the latest episode of F&I Today, Paul Brown, Vice President...
CBT News
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.