TSLA414.210-8.03%
GM74.435-0.425%
F13.215-0.185%
RIVN13.330-0.4599%
CYD49.320-0.68%
HMC25.195-0.985%
TM187.515-3.165%
CVNA67.1900.02%
PAG160.740-1.44%
LAD266.3404.42%
AN184.5400.38999%
GPI316.0702.45%
ABG178.730-0.44%
SAH73.480-0.48%
TSLA414.210-8.03%
GM74.435-0.425%
F13.215-0.185%
RIVN13.330-0.4599%
CYD49.320-0.68%
HMC25.195-0.985%
TM187.515-3.165%
CVNA67.1900.02%
PAG160.740-1.44%
LAD266.3404.42%
AN184.5400.38999%
GPI316.0702.45%
ABG178.730-0.44%
SAH73.480-0.48%
TSLA414.210-8.03%
GM74.435-0.425%
F13.215-0.185%
RIVN13.330-0.4599%
CYD49.320-0.68%
HMC25.195-0.985%
TM187.515-3.165%
CVNA67.1900.02%
PAG160.740-1.44%
LAD266.3404.42%
AN184.5400.38999%
GPI316.0702.45%
ABG178.730-0.44%
SAH73.480-0.48%

Tackling the HARD NO with Your Customers

customers

For years, F&I managers have been successful at payment manipulation and repair scare for customers. We have learned how to extend the term and use fancy closing techniques to close down the payment buyer.

What happens when the customer gives us the hard no? When they shut us down immediately telling us they do not want any of our products?

I will tell you what happens. Most F&I managers freeze up and move forward with the paperwork.

customers
Photo Courtesy of Adam Marburger

In this industry, we have focused most of our efforts on the payment buyer and not the value buyer. Does the value buyer have different needs than the payment buyer? My experience tells me that most of our customers are looking for these few things when they purchase a new vehicle:

  • The greatest use of enjoyment
  • The least amount of aggravation
  • The lowest total cost

By purchasing the service contract, you will never have to worry about paying for an unexpected repair or worry about having a car to drive. GUESS WHAT? That’s just icing on the cake. The real magic is hidden and it’s up to you to explain. The reason ALL customers should purchase the service contract is it provides them an exit strategy. There is absolutely nothing that can add value to the vehicle like the service contract. Here are some reasons why:

  • It allows you to trade the car on your terms and not the vehicles. I’ve watched several customers trade in their vehicle prematurely due to a problematic car. What happens is, you end up paying more in depreciation, interest and sales tax.
  • It allows you to receive more money for your trade. The sales manager would much rather put more money in a trade that has a service contract.
  • It allows you to keep the car longer, saves depreciation, interest, sales tax.
  • A policy is cancelable or transferable.
  • The customer has options that they would never experience without the service contract.

Try this

When the customer declines, simply relax and ask, “What is the main reason you are choosing to be unprotected.” They will tell you something like this:

  • I don’t ever buy those
  • I will assume the risk
  • I don’t believe in them

IT DOES NOT MATTER WHAT THEY SAY! The only reason the customer does not purchase the service contract is they do not know how to do the math. It’s up to us to show them.

Do not allow your customers previous experience with F&I dictate the outcome of their experience with you!

Slow down and explain how the customer is not just paying a premium to cover repairs. They are investing in an exit strategy that will give them options and those options will save thousands.

F&I

More from F&I
Why 'decision fatigue' is killing your F&I gross

Why ‘decision fatigue’ is killing your F&I gross

- May 14, 2026
Buying a car demands more decisions than many customers expect. By the time they sign the purchase agreement, "decision fatigue" has set in. They have already negotiated a price, settled...
Getting more buyers across the finish line

Getting more buyers across the finish line

- May 13, 2026
Every car shopping journey has its highs and lows. On the positive side, it’s fun to do test drives and it’s exhilarating to drive off the lot in a new...
Finance Director Symphony Wills shares her success story

Finance Director shares path from rejection to BMW rooftop success

- May 12, 2026
Symphony Wills did not stumble into the car business. She chased it, fought rejection, and took on a two-hour commute to get her foot in the door and onto the...
Affordability squeeze reshapes F&I strategy as dealers rethink customer conversations

Affordability squeeze reshapes F&I strategy as dealers rethink customer conversations

- May 7, 2026
Rising costs are reshaping how customers approach car buying, and F&I leaders must adjust their strategies to keep pace. On the latest episode of F&I Today, Paul Brown, Vice President...
CBT News
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.