TSLA378.7308.14%
GM80.2301.96%
F12.1450.045%
RIVN14.6000.3%
CYD31.870-0.08%
HMC31.7800.43%
TM184.1202.63%
CVNA63.690-0.08%
PAG200.590-3.44%
LAD303.000-4.77%
AN161.670-0.79%
GPI241.440-8.4%
ABG171.830-4.05%
SAH62.630-0.2%
TSLA378.7308.14%
GM80.2301.96%
F12.1450.045%
RIVN14.6000.3%
CYD31.870-0.08%
HMC31.7800.43%
TM184.1202.63%
CVNA63.690-0.08%
PAG200.590-3.44%
LAD303.000-4.77%
AN161.670-0.79%
GPI241.440-8.4%
ABG171.830-4.05%
SAH62.630-0.2%
TSLA378.7308.14%
GM80.2301.96%
F12.1450.045%
RIVN14.6000.3%
CYD31.870-0.08%
HMC31.7800.43%
TM184.1202.63%
CVNA63.690-0.08%
PAG200.590-3.44%
LAD303.000-4.77%
AN161.670-0.79%
GPI241.440-8.4%
ABG171.830-4.05%
SAH62.630-0.2%

How dealers can maximize net profits amid inventory surpluses and declining sales

Where inventory levels are up along with interest rates and expenses, while customer interest in vehicle purchases and net profits are down.

Halfway through 2024 we are being challenged with another uncommon year in the car business, where inventory levels are up along with interest rates and expenses, while customer interest in vehicle purchases and net profits are down from expected forecasts.

If you have been in this business 40 plus years like I have and seeing the slowdowns for every imaginable reason, there is a few unflappable techniques that some dealers have focused on that allows them to not only sleep well at night but grow their net profits.

As the title implies; Variable sales are something that has ebbs and flows while Fixed Operations implies a more consistent income stream, but increased volume in Service with poor customer engagement rarely improves Service net profits. In fact, Advisors having more customers to handle in many cases causes sales/RO (repair order) to decline, leaving you with overworked and frustrated employees.

There are two areas in Service operations that are given extra focus during these times which are vendor partners and appointment preparations.

When it comes to vendor partners, these relationships can innocently increase over time always with the idea of helping grow the business or making life easier for an Advisor or Technician. When you factor in automatic renewable contracts, it is possible your management team is unaware of monthly invoices from vendors that have long since lost their effectiveness in driving in traffic or assisting Advisors or Technicians. A quick evaluation of the product’s performance with the staff may find it is not generating enough to pay for its monthly billing in increased business or efficiency.

Appointment preparation is a generic term that encompasses a vast array of strategies to put the Advisor in a position of knowledge and confidence when greeting a customer on an appointment arrival, with a goal of customer engagement. The only true growth opportunity in a Service operation is more approvals for additional needed services not more low profit oil changes. Don’t interpret that phrase to mean we don’t want a high level of retention with customer oil changes, just the opposite, we just don’t want that to be the only service done on that visit, if more is needed.

When an Advisor staff is unprepared and is discovering a customer’s needs during the moment of write-up and is busy concentrating on their tablet or desktop write-up they rarely have time to look up and really connect with their customer (a “who’s next” approach), the level of customer engagement is small at best. When does this lack of engagement show up you may ask? It is when an Advisor attempts to sell the additional needed services listed on the multipoint inspection. 

Having a structure day-before preparation process in place with Advisors reviewing the customer’s prime concerns (why they are coming in for service), the customer’s history, and what services are needed at their mileage interval, allows an Advisor to speak with confidence which builds trust with the client. More then money or time, the #1 reason customers decline additional needed services has always been a lack of Trust.

In conclusion, as new vehicle sales continue to stay soft and Service departments naturally increase in volume, this is the perfect opportunity to maximize net profits in your Fixed Operations. But a few words of caution are needed; vendor partners will want their cut of the production, and a lack of real structure in the service process will just create stress and chaos in a Service drive and no real growth in net profits!

Read More

More from Fixed-Ops
How Tom Wood Auto is fixing the technician shortage by running its own university

How Tom Wood Auto is fixing the technician shortage by running its own university

- October 5, 2026
Finding skilled technicians and service advisors remains a major fixed ops challenge. So, one dealer group is training its own. On today's edition of CBT Live, Bill Demaree, Corporate Director...
M5's Lee Harkins on unlocking hidden fixed ops revenue

M5’s Lee Harkins on unlocking hidden fixed ops revenue

- September 29, 2026
A few overlooked fixed ops numbers show where service revenue is slipping away. On today's edition of CBT Live, Lee Harkins, President and CEO of M5 Management Services, explains why additional...
Iran conflict driving up oil change costs, squeezing fixed ops margins

Iran conflict driving up oil costs, squeezing fixed ops margins

- September 28, 2026
On the Dash: Iran conflict disruptions are cutting oil suppliers' notice before price hikes to days, not weeks. Dealers now pay $5 to $7 more per oil change than they...
Service scheduling improves industry-wide, Volkswagen dealers lead the pack

Service scheduling improves industry-wide, Volkswagen dealers lead the pack

- September 15, 2026
On the Dash: Every brand in the study improved its service scheduling score, lifting the industry average 7 points Volkswagen ranked first overall, Volvo second, with Acura, BMW, Mazda and...
CBT News
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.