TSLA384.8904.78%
GM83.630-0.42%
F11.3450.005%
RIVN11.9000.02%
CYD22.1150.015%
HMC33.8700.05%
TM211.040-2.08%
CVNA73.0701.97%
PAG212.3600.09%
LAD296.1002.5%
AN178.7602.3%
GPI264.9656.525%
ABG198.1051.235%
SAH59.7601.11%
TSLA384.8904.78%
GM83.630-0.42%
F11.3450.005%
RIVN11.9000.02%
CYD22.1150.015%
HMC33.8700.05%
TM211.040-2.08%
CVNA73.0701.97%
PAG212.3600.09%
LAD296.1002.5%
AN178.7602.3%
GPI264.9656.525%
ABG198.1051.235%
SAH59.7601.11%
TSLA384.8904.78%
GM83.630-0.42%
F11.3450.005%
RIVN11.9000.02%
CYD22.1150.015%
HMC33.8700.05%
TM211.040-2.08%
CVNA73.0701.97%
PAG212.3600.09%
LAD296.1002.5%
AN178.7602.3%
GPI264.9656.525%
ABG198.1051.235%
SAH59.7601.11%


This is how you get robbed without anyone holding a gun

Private companies, license plate cameras and government fees are creating a new business around finding more ways to charge American drivers.

A camera photographs your car. A system identifies your license plate. A computer decides you owe money. A private company may collect a percentage. And you get the bill.

The views and opinions expressed by Lauren Fix are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of CBT News.

A camera photographs your car. A system identifies your license plate. A computer decides you owe money. A private company may collect a percentage. And you get the bill.

Welcome to the new business of taxing, tracking and penalizing American drivers. A $50 charge can become $150. A $100 ticket can become $486. Some places are finding entirely new ways to charge you just for showing up. These aren’t hypothetical examples. There are real programs, real contracts and real money changing hands.

The question is no longer just how much government can collect from motorists. It’s who is making money helping government find them.

Connecticut offers a revealing example. New Haven hired Municipal Tax Services, a private company that uses vehicles equipped with automatic license plate readers to identify cars that may belong on the city’s property tax rolls. The company photographs plates, records where vehicles are spotted and investigates whether they should be taxed in New Haven.

The contract gives MTS a 38% commission for each vehicle added to the tax rolls. The vehicle owner is also charged a $50 company fee. New Haven reported that MTS recovered nearly $24 million between 2024 and 2025. Applying the commission rate to that figure produces an estimated $9 million, although that is a calculation, not a confirmed payment total.

Sign up for CBT News’ daily newsletter and get the latest industry stories delivered straight to your inbox.

The financial incentive is obvious: the more vehicles the company identifies and successfully adds to the tax rolls, the more money it can potentially make. What happens when it identifies the wrong vehicle?

Paul and Kathy Garasimowicz of North Branford received a New Haven tax bill after MTS photographed their family Nissan in the city. Their son had used the car while attending college and working in New Haven. The couple provided proof of their North Branford residence and evidence that they had already paid their vehicle taxes there. They say their documentation was initially rejected. Eventually, the New Haven Board of Assessment Appeals dropped the assessment.

Connecticut law does allow a municipality to tax a vehicle principally kept there. Simply driving into another town, however, does not automatically make a car taxable there. That distinction matters when a private contractor is collecting location data and earning a commission tied to the outcome.

Who independently verifies the company’s findings before a bill goes out? Why should drivers have to fight a private contractor to prove where they live? A mistake can become an expensive, time-consuming problem for the motorist, while the company has a financial reason to find more vehicles.

New York City lawmakers are considering another approach. Senate Bill S6402 and its Assembly companion, A2563, would authorize a $50 fee on vehicles entering New York City if they are registered in states that do not cooperate with New York’s enforcement of certain traffic-camera violations. The bills are still in committee. This is a proposal, not a fee currently charged to every driver with an out-of-state plate.

Read that again. The proposal would allow a charge based on the state where your vehicle is registered, even if you personally have not committed a new traffic violation by entering the city. The sponsors argue that the measure is needed because some states do not provide information that New York City needs to enforce photo-monitoring penalties. That may be their rationale, but motorists should still ask why the answer is another fee and how the city will make sure the right vehicles are charged.

Maryland has taken a different step. Its Plate Where You Live program targets Maryland residents who keep out-of-state plates when state law requires them to register their vehicles in Maryland. Beginning October 1, 2026, owners receive a warning and 60 days to comply or establish an exemption. After that, the penalty can reach $7 per day, up to $420.

Continued noncompliance can lead to further action, including booting, towing or impoundment. This is not a fee on every out-of-state driver entering Maryland. It applies to residents who are required to register their vehicles there.

States have legitimate registration laws. People who move and establish residency generally have to register their vehicles accordingly. The issue is how enforcement works, whether people receive clear notice, and whether there is a fair way to challenge an error before penalties pile up.

Then there are traffic tickets that grow dramatically after the original violation. In California, CBS News investigated a red-light camera citation with a $100 violation amount but a total bail figure of $486. The difference came from a collection of assessments and fees added to traffic tickets over time, including charges supporting programs unrelated to the traffic offense. The driver paid a ticket-defense company $179 to fight the citation.

A $100 ticket becoming a $486 bill is not a minor administrative detail. It’s a financial burden more than four times the original violation. Drivers deserve to know what each charge is for, who receives the money and whether every assessment is legally authorized.

Long Island has already seen what happens when an extra fee goes too far. Suffolk County added a $30 administrative charge to its $50 red-light camera tickets for years. The county collected approximately $91 million in those fees between 2013 and 2023. A New York appeals court ruled the extra charge was not authorized under the law governing the camera program. Suffolk later agreed to a settlement providing up to $45 million for eligible drivers who file valid claims, subject to court approval. The claim deadline listed by the settlement administrator is December 8, 2026.

Think about that. Drivers paid the money first. After the fee was challenged and ruled unlawful, they had to pursue a refund. The county did not automatically put every dollar back into the hands of the people who paid it.

These examples are different, but they point to the same problem: government enforcement is becoming increasingly dependent on automated identification, data collection and private contractors. Some companies are paid commissions. Others are paid to process violations or provide enforcement technology. Those arrangements are not automatically improper, but they create financial incentives that deserve public scrutiny.

When a company gets paid based on how many vehicles it identifies or how much revenue it helps recover, the public should know exactly how that company is compensated. Who audits its work? Who checks the accuracy of its data? Who makes sure the contractor isn’t turning questionable matches into bills? Most importantly, who protects the driver when the system gets it wrong?

This is also a privacy issue. License plate readers can record where a vehicle is seen, when it is seen and how often it appears in a particular location. That information can be useful for legitimate investigations, but it also creates a record of people’s movements. Drivers should know how long that information is kept, who has access to it and what limits exist on its use.

The danger is not one camera or one tax bill. It’s the gradual expansion of a system in which a vehicle becomes a source of information, that information becomes a reason to investigate or charge someone, and the resulting revenue creates another incentive to expand the system. When private businesses stand to profit, transparency and independent oversight become even more important.

I’m not arguing that people should avoid legitimate taxes, ignore registration laws or escape responsibility for traffic violations. Drivers should follow the law. Government should enforce it. Private contractors should be held to the same standards of accuracy and accountability expected of the agencies hiring them.

What I will not accept is a system where a company can identify a vehicle, trigger a financial demand and collect a percentage while the owner struggles to prove the government got it wrong. A camera cannot tell the whole story. A license plate scan is not proof that someone owes a tax. An automated ticket should not be treated as unquestionable simply because a computer generated it.

The public needs to see the contracts, the payment arrangements, the error rates and the appeal procedures. If a program is truly about public safety or tax compliance, officials should have no problem explaining exactly how it works and where the money goes.

Your car is not a government revenue account, and your license plate should not become an open invitation for private companies to turn your movements into a business opportunity. The question every driver should be asking is simple: Who profits when you get caught, and who is protecting you when they get it wrong?


Check out my full commentary on this story: https://youtu.be/m_b5qFul84Q

Looking for more automotive news?  https://www.CarCoachReports.com

Listen and subscribe to The Drive with Lauren and Karl – https://www.youtube.com/@thedrivecarshow


More from Daily Automotive News
SUPERCARS, SCANDALS & OFF-ROAD WARS! BUGATTI, GM & HYUNDAI

SUPERCARS, SCANDALS & OFF-ROAD WARS! BUGATTI, GM & HYUNDAI

- November 18, 2026
You buy a car, make the payments, pay for insurance, and cover the repairs. But what happens when the vehicle you own starts collecting information about you and sharing it...

Five Star Automotive Group acquires seven Indiana dealerships from Dreyer & Reinbold

- November 17, 2026
Five Star Automotive Group acquired seven metro Indianapolis dealerships and their related real estate from Dreyer & Reinbold Inc. on November 16, 2026. The transaction includes BMW, Infiniti and Mini...
Tesla wants your car keys – and you might not get them back

Tesla wants your car keys – and you might not get them back

- November 16, 2026
Elon Musk wants to change the way Americans think about driving, and his latest move should get every car owner’s attention. Tesla is winding down Cybertruck production at its Texas...
Piazza Auto Group acquires Hill Cadillac in Pennsylvania

Piazza Auto Group acquires Hill Cadillac in Pennsylvania

- November 13, 2026
Piazza Auto Group acquired Hill Cadillac in Newtown Square, Pennsylvania, from the Hill family, adding to its operations in the Delaware Valley. The dealership, led by Geoffrey Hill Sr. and...

Add us as a preferred source on Google

CBT News
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.