TSLA327.3505.27%
GM88.3100.63%
F14.240-0.19%
RIVN15.7600.405%
CYD48.1201.63%
HMC30.1200.52%
TM189.1703%
CVNA68.0301.9%
PAG219.0501.55%
LAD370.990-6.92%
AN215.6000.17%
GPI285.880-6.26%
ABG222.850-5.12%
SAH88.2701.04%
TSLA327.3505.27%
GM88.3100.63%
F14.240-0.19%
RIVN15.7600.405%
CYD48.1201.63%
HMC30.1200.52%
TM189.1703%
CVNA68.0301.9%
PAG219.0501.55%
LAD370.990-6.92%
AN215.6000.17%
GPI285.880-6.26%
ABG222.850-5.12%
SAH88.2701.04%
TSLA327.3505.27%
GM88.3100.63%
F14.240-0.19%
RIVN15.7600.405%
CYD48.1201.63%
HMC30.1200.52%
TM189.1703%
CVNA68.0301.9%
PAG219.0501.55%
LAD370.990-6.92%
AN215.6000.17%
GPI285.880-6.26%
ABG222.850-5.12%
SAH88.2701.04%

3 Tips for a Smoother Subprime F&I Experience

subprime

If your dealership works in the subprime space at all, you already understand the challenges that come with these deals. Tighter restrictions on payment, income verification, and a sometimes hostile or uncomfortable exchange between F&I and the borrower.

How can this process be easier for both and still result in a car delivered and a decent PRU? Let’s take a look at 3 ways F&I can help make this already difficult buying scenario a little easier for everyone…

  1. Servant Attitude – Your role is to execute the paperwork, sell aftermarket products, and make sure the deal is airtight for the lender. With the subprime borrower, this entire process can be more difficult. The customer may not know how bad their credit is and if so, they can become hostile if this information is presented in a way that make them defensive.

If you as the F&I manager already know this presentation could go bad, then take steps ahead of time to ensure the borrower won’t get defensive. Do not talk down to them. Don’t treat them any differently than you would treat an A-paper buyer. Talk to them with respect and have all the tools you need to help walk them through their options. Show empathy and approach every subprime borrower as the person who can best help them drive off in the car they need.

  1. Drill Down on Income Verification – Stips are a pain but a necessary evil for all of your subprime lenders. Collect as much income information as you can. Don’t be afraid to ask the more uncomfortable questions regarding additional sources of income from child support, alimony, or other monthly sources that could help. Don’t take the initial credit application at face value. Many borrowers may not be aware what other income can help them qualify. Your job is to educate them on this process and help them create a favorable outcome with the lender. 
  2. Be Creative – Even though there may be little room in the payment for product, don’t be afraid to be creative when positioning it to the buyer. Go through the same selling steps you would with any other A-paper buyer. Explain how credit life/A&H can help preserve their credit in case of job loss or injury. If they live in the city and have to park on the street, explain how GAP (if your store is allowed to sell it) can help make sure they are not paying out of pocket in case of a loss.

subprime

If you have asked all the right questions, you can still hold a solid PRU even with a subprime loan and do it in a way that reduces the chance for a chargeback. Maybe only one product will ‘fit’ with the payment…so make sure it is a product the borrower feels will help them the most.

If you treat the subprime borrower as a you would any other buyer first, the rest of the process should be easy. Your professionalism and empathy can go a long way to ensuring goodwill and repeat business from them as well as referrals in the future. Trust me, they will remember your kindness and servant attitude when they pay that car off and are ready for a new one.

More from F&I
How profit participation can help dealers build long-term wealth

How profit participation can help dealers build long-term wealth

- August 4, 2026
For many dealers, F&I profitability doesn't end when a vehicle leaves the showroom. Behind the scenes, participation programs can create another revenue stream by allowing retailers to share in the...
Fighting payment anxiety in the F&I office with empathy and value

Fighting payment anxiety in the F&I office with empathy and value

- July 16, 2026
Payment anxiety is climbing, and the squeeze isn't just at the dealership. Rising rates, pricier vehicles and mounting negative equity are pushing monthly payments higher, and customers are watching every...
F&I office most trusted, but pain points remain, CDK Global survey finds

F&I office most trusted, but pain points remain, CDK Global survey finds

- July 9, 2026
Customers trust the F&I office more than any other part of the dealership visit, even as long wait times and duplicated paperwork continue to frustrate them. That's according to CDK...
The overlooked F&I process that builds trust, boosts profitability 

The overlooked F&I process that builds trust, boosts profitability 

- July 9, 2026
Today's car buyers expect a transparent, efficient purchasing experience from start to finish. On the latest episode of F&I Today, Paul Brown, VP of Ascent Dealer Services, explains why the...
CBT News
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.